DreamLyrics™ Play-by-Post
Posted By: nem Q4 2017 Genre Survey - Vote and Be Counted! - Tue 21/11/17 19:32 UTC
OK I got the message! The Q4 survey is late! blaze

Well before we get into the voting, let's reflect on Q2's results.

The following choices received 4 votes each, tying them in first place.

  • Classic Fantasy
  • Dark Fantasy
  • Post-Apoc
  • Supers


The unsatiable demand for fantasy. Probably explains D&D's continued popularity! jk But there is something joyously free and easy about fantasy, and that's a good fit for a message game that will be played over many months, years even.

It's quite hard to break the suspension of disbelief in fantasy, and you can have big swingy variations in tone, pacing, in theme, so the game can stay fresh. Dark fantasy though? Intriguing! How dark is 'dark'? Did anyone a particular product or IP in mind?

Post-apocalypse and supers are traditionally difficult to pull-off, but remain a popular survey choice. Have GMs and/or players become shy of them, do you think?

Hmm. hmm

Anyway, without further ado, let's get voting! As before you have 2 votes. smile
Posted By: nem Re: Q4 2017 Genre Survey - Vote and Be Counted! - Wed 22/11/17 20:09 UTC
And yes, hello, why is this topic appearing at the top of your forum?

It's set to global over the weekend, so everyone should see it (and vote hopefully). Come Monday, 27 Nov, it will revert to a normal topic, appearing only in Message Gaming Centre.
Posted By: nem Re: Q4 2017 Genre Survey - Vote and Be Counted! - Wed 29/11/17 11:35 UTC
Big showing for more classic fantasy. elvis In RPG terms, that generally points a finger straight at D&D. Is that what people had in mind by 'Classic Fantasy', or is it something else?
Posted By: Gypsy Re: Q4 2017 Genre Survey - Vote and Be Counted! - Wed 29/11/17 12:18 UTC
Or 13th Age wink
Posted By: MikeD Re: Q4 2017 Genre Survey - Vote and Be Counted! - Wed 29/11/17 13:30 UTC
To be honest, there are lots of decent 'fantasy game systems' ... but which one doesn't matter as much as the story and the characters.
Posted By: nem Re: Q4 2017 Genre Survey - Vote and Be Counted! - Thu 30/11/17 22:54 UTC
True. Though did anyone have a setting in mind, an adventure, or theme perhaps? Or, did anyone have a fantasy character concept that they were wanting to play?

Btw, always up for more 13th Age, Gypsy. wink
Posted By: Pandemonium Re: Q4 2017 Genre Survey - Vote and Be Counted! - Fri 01/12/17 15:16 UTC
I have been reading Symbaroum which is dark fantasy. Interesting roll under game mechanic.
© DreamLyrics Play-by-Post